“She/[He] don’t have to know.”
-John Legend “She Don’t Have to Know”
Season’s Greetings and welcome to another edition of “She Said, He Said”. For those of you who came to the blog last week looking for a new post and were disappointed not to find one, we would like to thank you for your addiction and hope you keep coming back. It was Thanksgiving week and while many of you were out of the office and enjoying quality time with family and friends, so were we. We hope you had a great holiday and a relaxing break because we certainly did. But, we’re back now and we promise never to leave you hanging again. Unless, of course, Jay Z and Beyonce call. But that’s understandable right?
Today’s topic ladies and gentlemen is privacy. What is it and does it, or even should it, exist within the construct of a monogamous relationship? We know it definitely exists when dealing with a “jump-off” because there are questions neither party gets to ask and neither party is obligated to answer by the very nature of the relationship! However, when it comes to monogamy, questions are raised. The concept of a monogamous relationship is that two people who care about each other choose and consent to date, sex and co-mingle with each other and ONLY each other. They share food, space and bodily fluids, but the question is should they share secrets. Here is where the writers of this blog differ. She says, “Absolutely” and he says, “(Hell) No.”
He Says
A wise man once said, “secrets don’t make friends.” Let’s be honest, that wasn’t a man who said that, it was a woman who wanted the password to her man’s cell phone. Guys always have and always will believe in keeping secrets. In turn, women always have and always will believe in NOT having secrets, except for when it comes to: girl talk; how much she spent shopping; and her significant other’s business. And herein lies the problem.
I don’t believe in a blanket prohibition on sharing secrets. Certainly, there are things that should be shared between partners. When it comes to health, home and family there shouldn’t be any secrets except when it is absolutely necessary. You shouldn’t keep secrets from your significant other about your diabetes, heart condition or that bump in your nether regions that you’re clearly concerned about. You shouldn’t hide from your partner the fact that there is a leak in the basement which ruined the Christmas ornaments and the man cave. And you certainly shouldn’t conceal the fact that your crazy Uncle Joe, the one whose favorite candy is booger sugar, asked if he could crash at your place for a few days (weeks) until he gets back on his feet. Certain things should be shared. However, I do not believe in mandatory disclosure for most topics outside of those mentioned above.
The fact of the matter is that before you decided to engage in this “monogamy experiment” you were your own person and if the relationship doesn’t work out, you’ll still be your own person. While you’re merging your life, space and finances with someone else, you can’t lose your individuality and sense of identity. For example, there are some things that your friends share with you that shouldn’t be shared with your partner. If you tell one too many stories about that “loose” friend, your partner will begin to question whether you’re birds of a feather. Tell too many secrets about your torrid past and your significant other may never look at you the same way again. Some things in the past should stay there and only be brought to the present in your head.
However, those are not the only kinds of secrets that arise in relationships. The other secrets people in relationships often keep are those things you know will hurt your partner but you have NO DESIRE to share, i.e., unsightly weight gain, a meal your significant other worked on all day that you wouldn’t feed to your pet or the fact that you really don’t like your partner’s mom. Should those things be shared when you know your partner will flip out like Carey (who is Carey? This is lost on me so it may be lost on others) or is it better to safeguard those secrets and keep them to yourself for the sake of peace? The best answer is to keep some things to yourself.
Not everything that goes on between you and your friends, at work, or even throughout the course of the day is fodder for conversation at the dinner table or on the couch with your significant other. Some jokes you share with friends over the phone won’t be funny to someone else, especially if it’s about the kid with the helmet you guys used to pick on, or the girl who you harassed because her shirt never quite covered her larger than normal mid section so it’s okay to keep this information to yourself.
Is it a crime to hide these things? Is it a tragedy that you don’t share everything? I certainly don’t think so. Just because you share space, finances and may have merged your DNA doesn’t mean that you have to share everything. Share the important things: life, love, memories, and family but keep the inside jokes, email passwords and location of secret C.I.A. missions close to the vest.
She Says
“Lies and secrets, they are like a cancer in the soul. They eat away what is good and leave only destruction behind.”
-Cassandra Clare, Clockwork Prince
Here’s the thing about secrets and relationships for me: I’m not really concerned about the little secrets that were referenced above because 99% of the time, people don’t care about what their significant other and his/her best friend talked about last night or last week. Most people don’t even really want to know EVERY little detail about their significant other’s past because it may start to taint the way they look at you, feel about you, think about you, judge you and trust you which is detrimental to your relationship.
So yes, I agree with him that secrets will always be kept in relationships. For instance, if you buy your significant other a Christmas gift in February, you will have to keep it a secret until December 25th. If your best friend tells you something and asks you not to tell anyone, you need to keep that secret because your best friend was likely there long before your significant other and will likely be there long after your significant other, if your relationship might don’t make it. So while secrets are a natural part of life, not all secrets are good secrets to have when you’re in a relationship. More specifically, I’m talking about bad secrets, the ones that can often break a relationship; those secrets that cripple the foundation of relationships, destroy couples and debilitate a relationship that could otherwise be amazing.
Let’s take a step back and revisit the concept of cheating for a brief moment. As we discussed in Cheating: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (http://driveme2drink.blogspot.com/2012/11/cheating-good-bad-and-ugly.html), cheating is not just a physical act, it can also be an emotional act and this is where having secrets in relationships gets ugly. Let’s look at a few examples:
1) A man in a monogamous relationship is constantly texting some other chick who is his “friend” at all hours of the night. However, the texts are flirty and would be wholly offensive to his girl. There are sexual innuendos, pictures, and terms of endearment being tossed around, but he continues to tell his girl the other chick is just a friend. She knows her man talks to this friend fairly regularly and she’s cool with it, but she has no idea that they’re having these types of conversation because he keeps those major details a secret. Herein lies the problem. Aside from the fact that something like this should NEVER happen because it is wrong on so many levels, his secrets are negatively impacting his relationship, whether he knows it or not. While he thinks it’s not that serious because nothing is ever going to happen between them, she knows how much he loves his girl and she knows they are just friends, he is diverting attention away from his relationship and investing it somewhere else, and one may think he is also engaging in emotional infidelity. Plus, I’m pretty sure his girl would be fire hot if she knew her man was carrying on these types of conversations with old girl, and that is why he keeps it a secret. Yet, if it wasn’t that serious, why didn’t he tell his girl about the nature of these conversations with his friend? Because he knows that his behavior is not okay. So, he has to keep it a secret because it might get him left, cut, or running from flying plates. Good secret? I think not.
2) A dude has asked his girl to stop talking to her ex because he doesn’t trust that dude. He thinks the guy is still trying to get at her, he’s not feeling how he treated her during their relationship and he feels disrespected by that relationship. Yet, she continues to talk to the ex via gchat, text message, and email on occasion. She may even see him every so often-nothing remotely romantic or inappropriate-but that’s her friend and they are cool. Well, one day, they run into each other on the street and are just talking about life, work, his new relationship, etc. for like 20 minutes-nothing major. She gets home from work, her man asks about her day, and she tells him about the entire day EXCEPT for the random run-in with her ex. She chooses to omit that part of her day and keep her encounter a secret. Even though nothing happened and nothing went down, she has a secret because she did something that she knew was problematic. Good secret? I don’t think so. Yes, this may be one of those secrets he referenced earlier (the kind you keep to avoid hurting your significant other in an effort to keep the peace), but why engage in behavior that you have to keep a secret especially when you know your significant other’s position/feelings/emotions on that issue? As I said, secrets can do major damage to your relationship and, the way I see it, it’s easier to just tell the truth and face the consequences up front instead of getting caught later on. No matter how tightly secrets are kept, some always come to light and when your significant other finds out that you lied/omitted information/or kept a secret of this magnitude, trust, faith and your relationship may be down the drain…and for what?
I could go on and on with examples illustrating the detrimental effects of keeping secrets in relationships; however, my point is that secrets, in and of themselves, are not the problem. The types of secrets people keep are the problem. Secrets will always exist, but if you feel you have to lie or omit information just to kick it, the secret you possess probably isn’t a good secret. In a relationship, you should be able to be open and honest with your significant other about all things-be they good or bad-no matter what the other person’s response may be, that’s called maturity. I recognize that sometimes omissions may occur to keep the peace, but the real question one should ask when deciding whether to keep a secret is: If my partner ever finds out about this secret, what will it do to our relationship? Will he/she leave me? Will he/she stop trusting me? Will he/she believe that I have deceived/hurt/disrespected him/her? Will he/she even care? If you have any semblance of care and concern for your significant other and your relationship, the answers to these questions will clearly guide you on what to do about disclosing information to your boo. Bottom line as I see it, those secrets that could negatively impact or affect the nature of your relationship and all the important components of monogamy such as trust, honest, respect and loyalty have no place in your relationship. In my opinion, if you keep secrets that you know will cause hurt and pain to your partner, either you shouldn’t have those secrets or maybe you don’t need to be in a relationship. Just a thought.
It is clear that we have differing opinions on the topic of privacy in relationships. He says: secrets are ok in limited situations and she says: there are very few instances in which secrets are okay. We said it from the beginning and have echoed this time and time again, we won’t always agree, which is the beauty of this blog. Men and women often see things differently and we strive to share those views and maybe save a relationship or 2 in the process.